Why do PENTECOSTALS care so much about SPIRIT BAPTISM?

This post is part of my current blog series called “Questions People Ask about the Holy Spirit” (#HSQuestions). Thank you to everyone who submitted questions! You can still submit questions here

Sometimes I think Pentecostals should just give up on talking about Spirit baptism. The students who sit in my classes and were raised in Pentecostal churches are confused about the whole thing. And I’ve had people crying in my office because they want to experience it, but haven’t.

And, of course, some Christians think it’s just stupid.

But, there it is in the Bible. Staring back at us. Calling us to something more.

Jesus obviously cared about it. He told his disciples to stay in Jerusalem until they were baptized in the Spirit (Luke 24:49, Acts 1:5).

Other than that, why do Pentecostals care so much about Spirit baptism?

It’s not just tongues. Nope.

I was 14 years old when I had the experience that Pentecostals call Spirit baptism. I was at church camp, the only possible place where anything spiritually good can happen. 🙂

The steel concave walls made the sanctuary, or tabernacle, as we called it, look more like a steel barn than a church. The preaching finished and the Pastor issued an altar call. I walked to the front and stood there singing the slow worship choruses as the band played their guitars and the keyboard on stage.

As I stood there with my hands raised and eyes closed, someone approached me. “Are you here because you want to be baptized in the Holy Spirit?”

I wasn’t too sure what he meant, but it sounded good. After all, I eagerly desired to have “more of God,” as the preachers put it.

He lead me in a prayer: “God, I ask you to now baptize me in the Spirit.” I thought this meant being slain in the Spirit, so I let myself fall backwards. He was kind enough to catch me. (Give me a break, I was 14.)

As I laid there on the cold, musty carpet,  I must have remembered a sermon or something because somehow I realized that Spirit baptism wasn’t the same as being slain in the Spirit.

I think I prayed the prayer again. Then . . . Peace. Love.

And as a result, I will





It was as though I had been released from a spiritual slingshot of growth.

My parents often came into my room late at night to turn the light off because I had fallen asleep reading my Bible. I spent an hour in prayer every morning as I walked door-to-door around the neighborhood delivering the local newspaper.

My wife remembers watching me and my pale, blond-haired friend (you know who you are) at church with our arms raised in worship as high as they would go.

And I wore a big wooden cross around my neck that was formed out of the letters jeSus (now it hangs on my wife’s mirror). Friends at school had no doubt I was a Christian, and I had the privilege of leading a few people to faith in Christ before I graduated from High School and made the long drive to Bible College.

And now I’m a Pentecostal theology professor. (And so utterly grateful for my “job” at Horizon College & Seminary!)

Way back in 1906 when the Pentecostal movement was still in its infancy, one participant in the Azusa Street revival exclaimed, “It was a baptism of love. Such abounding love! Such compassion seemed to almost kill me with its sweetness! People don’t know what they are doing when they stand out against it. . . .This baptism fills us with divine love” (see this and other testimonies here).

Or, in other words, as my own Pentecostal denomination states it, through Spirit baptism “the believer comes to know Christ in a more intimate way and receives power to witness and grow spiritually.”

In case you missed it, it isn’t just about tongues.

But, if you are anxiously wondering, yes, I did pray in tongues that night at church camp.

In the many years since I attended that camp, my thinking about Spirit baptism has expanded, but I still value the post-conversion experience of being baptized in the Spirit.

If you want to read more about how my thoughts about Spirit baptism have evolved, see especially my articles:

I’ve also written a couple blog posts on the topic:

I suppose I shouldn’t have been surprised at how many questions people submitted about Spirit baptism. I will not write every post on the topic, but it is going to come up a lot. You asked for it!

Question: What is your story of Spirit baptism? What has it meant for you?

If you enter an email address, it will not be published. Please keep your comments kind and relevant to the post.

Leave a Reply

12 thoughts on “Why do PENTECOSTALS care so much about SPIRIT BAPTISM?

  1. Great post. I remember being super cynical as a young teen when people were falling under the power of God. I assumed they were being pushed or manipulated. Then one day, I went up to the front of the church because I wanted more of God in my life…and I fell backwards…without anyone even praying for me…and there were no catchers…and I fell into a baseboard electric heater, but felt no pain then or after. I also REALLY appreciate your view on tongues not being the exclusive evidence for the Baptism of the Holy Spirit. I know a great many spirit-filled people who’ve never experienced tongues. As someone who grew up in the Pentecostal church and pastored in several of them, I always subscribed to the view that tongues is A evidence of spirit baptism, but not the initial or best evidence (that would be the fruit of the Spirit and Spirit filled life evident in the believer). When I stated this in my credentials interview with the PAOC, they certainly all agreed. I think it would be a really good idea for the PAOC to loosen up a bit on their “must speak in tongues to be a pastor” policy, so that you don’t have quite as many students in tears about missing out on something that we really shouldn’t be so heavily focused on in the first place. As you say- it’s the being FILLED/EMPOWERED by the Holy Spirit that matters.

  2. So true. Great thoughts. I’m thankful for the initial evidence of tongues. But show me a desire to share the gospel and a little love, joy, peace, patience….

  3. Terrific,I doubted and mocked it cause I came from,United Church background,challenged the Lord at 30,I felt waves of electricy flow and never been the same again,Thank you Holy Spirit,I am now 72 and moving in the Spiritual realm you 6 year old has utterances and laughsGod Blessings on everyone.